“WHAT and IF are two words as non-threatening as can be, but put them together side-by-side, and they have the power to haunt you for the rest of your life.”
(Lise Friedman)
WHAT-IF some things I prayed for really happened? Recently, I was praying for something that I thought was extremely and spiritually important to me. Day after day I included it in my morning and evening prayers genuinely believing it was in my best interest. How could I possibly be turned down?
But it didn’t happen. Later, I realized that if the prayer had been answered, it would have led to a deeply regrettable mistake. My disappointment then felt selfish and ungrateful. My intent, in this article, was to explore my own reaction and impact of the many “WHAT-IFs” in my life, past and present.
My husband would tell me there are always three answers to prayers )and questions: ) “yes,” “no,” or “maybe.” “Maybe” often feels most difficult for me when a prayer is not answered as I hoped. It may mean the timing is not right, the request needs clearer direction, or a reason beyond my understanding is failing to answer me with a simple “yes” or “no.”
I tried to make peace with that idea a few years ago when my husband died after a routine procedure. For nearly a year beforehand, I had been seriously ill. After I was finally diagnosed and received life-saving surgery, he died unexpectedly two weeks later. Perhaps his prayer was answered, while mine—to spare his life—was not. That painful WHAT-IF, wondering how life might have been different if our circumstances were reversed, stayed with me long after his death.
That experience did not give me easy answers, but it changed the way I think about unanswered prayers. It reminded me that not every silence is rejection, and not every unanswered prayer means God is absent.
When Prayers Are Unanswered
I reflected on this again after a stressful week. When a prayer goes unanswered, it is easy to feel abandoned or wonder if I have asked too much, too often. So, I challenged myself to look at both sides of my prayer: WHAT-IF it had been answered, but not in the way I wanted? WHAT-IF the answer I wanted created greater regret later? WHAT-IF I failed to see how it would affect me or others years later? Looking back, I can see that some unanswered or delayed prayers may have been blessings in disguise.
In my young adult years, I carried many bold dreams and wishful prayers. I wanted to join the military because I thought it would be exciting. I once believed I was in love with a man I knew only through letters and imagined marrying him and moving to another country. I was also offered a journalism job that would have placed me in the middle of breaking news, but I turned it down. At the time, each possibility felt thrilling, but I cautiously made other choices. Looking back, I thank God those prayers were not answered, or that I never followed through on them.
If those prayers had been answered, I might never have met my beloved husband and soulmate or created our beautiful family. I might not have spent our traveling years on hallowed American soil, grateful and safe. I might not have found work and volunteer opportunities that supported my values and the life I wanted to build. Those unanswered prayers helped shape who I became, and I do not regret the paths I didn’t take.
Belief in the Power of Prayer
I believe in the power of prayer. I also believe there can be a gift hidden in some unanswered prayers. That does not mean I never struggle when a prayer seems reasonable, sincere, and important, yet remains unanswered. In those moments, I have to remind myself that I am not in charge. Maybe God has other plans for my life.
WHAT-IF questions require deep thinking about our choices, relationships, and desires. I learned they could give me a new perspective on my most intimate feelings, the paths I traveled, and the future I still hoped for.
A little wooden heart hangs on my bathroom mirror with the words, Prayer. Let go and let God take over. It is easy to recite and remember, but much harder to practice. Surrendering the answer to “what will be, will be” can feel painfully difficult.
Of course, I want my prayers answered in the way I most desire, even though I know I have no control over the answer. Many prayers come from sincere hope for healing, joy, safety, peace, and meaningful change for myself, and those I love. People pray through illness, grief, war, abuse, fear, job loss, and natural disaster. And sometimes, I slip in a small prayer that may not seem important in the bigger picture but still matters deeply to me. Recognizing that difference can put my own desires in perspective.
When “Why?” Changes My Perception
I continue to learn that the “why” behind an unanswered prayer may never be revealed. After my son’s death, I searched relentlessly for an answer to why he took his life. Eventually, I accepted that knowing why would not have changed what happened. Not everything can be explained by destiny. In time, I had to accept that the answer I wanted would not bring my son back or heal my loss. Some things occur randomly; others may hold a purpose that I can’t see.
- Trust. I’ve learned to trust that even when I don’t understand, it may or may not be a deliberate motivator that changes my path or life.
- Grounded in faith. When my faith is weak in times of turmoil, I still know God answers prayers. Perhaps this time my prayer doesn’t align with his plan. He is in control.
- Grateful. I am grateful for the many prayers that were answered when they mattered most.
- Strength to “let go” Instead of asking why my prayer wasn’t answered, I ask for strength to let it go and make a better choice.”
Then, in one bright, shining, unforgettable moment, I recognize that a prayer has been answered. The silence breaks. The veil lifts. I receive the job or opportunity, meet the right person, recover from a health issue, heal a family wound, or simply make it through the struggle. Maybe the answer does not come exactly as I expected, but it turns out better than I ever imagined.
I thank God for many unanswered prayers. Fortunately, I seldom look back on those WHAT-IFs. My mother used to say, “If wishes were horses, beggars would ride.” My life may not have been as glamorous or exciting as I once imagined, but I am right where God placed me and where He allowed me to thrive in different ways. My regrets are few. Perhaps some unanswered prayers truly are blessings in disguise.
___________________________
- Credit to the words in a song that Garth Brooks wrote and released “Unanswered Prayers” in 1989.